Welcome To My Blog. I respect and appreciate comments, questions, information and theories you might have. Even if i agree with you or not, i won't delete your comments as long as they are not purposefully attacking anyone. I will not condone bullying of any kind. If you that is your intent, don't bother posting because i will delete it the moment i see it.

Sunday, July 15, 2018

Elvis: Suspicious minds... Is he really dead?

Elvis Presley
"Until we meet again, may god bless you as he has blessed me."

Elvis Aaron Presley was born in Tupelo, Mississippi in January 8, 1935. He was an American singer and actor and regarded as one of the most significant cultural icons of the 20th century.

The Beginning
His parents were Gladys Love and Vernon Elvis Presley.
The family attended an Assembly of God church, where he found his initial musical inspiration. His family was so poor that they often relied on government support. In 1938, they lost their home after his dad was found guilty of altering a check written by his landowner and sometime employer. He received his first guitar for his birthday in 1941. He failed a music class during his high school and was considered quiet and an outsider.
He intended to give his first recordings, “My Happiness” and “That’s When Your Heartaches Begin” as a gift to his mother in 1953. His music career began there in 1954, when he was 19 years old. He recorded at Sun Records with producer Sam Phillips, who wanted to bring the sound of African American music to a wider audience. He was accompanied by guitarist Scotty Moore and bassist Bill Black. In 1955, he signed with RCA Records and drummer D. J. Fontana joined the group.
 In January 1956, he delivered his first No. 1 single with “Heartbreak Hotel.”
He signed a movie contract with Paramount Pictures in 1956 and as expected, “Love Me Tender,” proved to be his 1st box office hit.
Elvis bought his mansion, Graceland, in Memphis, TN in 1957 for $100,000.  
He was inducted into the Army in 1957 and served in Germany till 1960. During this period, his mother, Gladys, died. 
While in Germany, his spirits were lifted when he met his future wife, Priscilla Beaulieu. She was 14 years old. Elvis was a sleepwalker when he was a kid. The sleep disorders continued when he was in the army, where he found it difficult to wake up early every morning as he couldn’t sleep all night. He donated his army pay to charities.Leaving behind his army life in 1960, Presley revived his music career with commercially successful work. He devoted much of the 1960s to making Hollywood movies and soundtrack albums, most of them critically derided. Shortly before Christmas 1966, Elvis proposed to Priscilla Beaulieu. 
They were married on May 1, 1967, in a brief ceremony in their suite at the Aladdin Hotel in Las Vegas.
His only child, Lisa Marie, was born on February 1, 1968, during a period when he had grown deeply unhappy with his career. In 1968, following a seven-year break from live performances, he returned to the stage in the acclaimed television comeback special Elvis, which led to an extended Las Vegas concert residency and a string of highly profitable tours. 
Cassandra Peterson, later television's Elvira, met Presley during this period in Las Vegas. She was working as a showgirl. 
This is what she had to say about meeting Elvis:
 "He was so anti-drug when I met him. I mentioned to him that I smoked marijuana, and he was just appalled. He said, 'Don't ever do that again.'"
On December 21, 1970, Elvis met with President Richard Nixon at the White House. He expressed his patriotism and explained how he believed he could reach out to the hippies to help combat the drug culture he and the president abhorred.
In 1971, an affair he had with Joyce Bova resulted, without his knowledge, in her pregnancy and an abortion.
The Presleys separated on February 23, 1972, after Priscilla told Elvis she had a relationship with Mike Stone, a karate instructor Elvis had recommended to her.
Five months later, Presley's new girlfriend, Linda Thompson, a songwriter and one-time Memphis beauty queen, moved in with him.
 In 1973, six years after their marriage, Elvis and Priscilla Beaulieu Presley got divorced. Also in  1973, Presley gave the first concert by a solo artist to be broadcast around the world, Aloha from Hawaii. At a midnight in February, four men rushed onto the stage in an apparent attack. Security men came to Elvis' defense, and the singer's karate instinct took over as he ejected one of them from the stage himself. Following the show, he became obsessed with the idea that the men had been sent by Mike Stone to kill him. Elvis raged, "There's too much pain in me ... Stone (must) die." 

After another two full days of raging, Red West, his friend and bodyguard, felt compelled to get a price for a contract killing and was relieved when Presley decided, "Aw hell, let's just leave it for now. Maybe it's a bit heavy."

Twice during the year, he overdosed on barbiturates. He spent three days in a coma in his hotel suite after the first incident. Towards the end of 1973, he was hospitalized, semi-comatose from the effects of pethidine addiction. According to his primary care physician, Dr. George C. Nichopoulos, Presley "felt that by getting (drugs) from a doctor, he wasn't the common everyday junkie getting something off the street".

Despite his failing health, in 1974, he undertook another intensive touring schedule. In 1976, he received the Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award at age 36, and has been inducted into multiple music halls of fame.
Elvis and Linda Thompson split in November 1976, and he took up with a new girlfriend, Ginger Alden.
He proposed to Ginger and gave her an engagement ring two months later.
Later
Journalist Tony Scherman wrote early 1977, "Presley had become a grotesque caricature of his sleek, energetic former self. Hugely overweight, his mind dulled by the pharmacopia he daily ingested, he was barely able to pull himself through his abbreviated concerts."
"Way Down", Elvis' last single issued during his career, was released on June 6. 
During the last six months of his life, he only performed one the song “Unchained Melody.” He was a broken man and even pleaded with Priscilla for the reunion. He suffered from multiple ailments: glaucoma, high blood pressure, liver damage, and an enlarged colon. Years of prescription drug abuse severely compromised his health, and he died suddenly in 1977 at his Graceland estate at the age of 42. Elvis was scheduled to fly out of Memphis to begin another tour. He was found dead that afternoon on his bathroom floor, by Ginger Alden. One witness stated "Elvis looked as if his entire body had completely frozen in a seated position while using the commode and then had fallen forward, in that fixed position, directly in front of it. It was clear that, from the time whatever hit him to the moment he had landed on the floor, Elvis hadn't moved."
His death was officially pronounced at 3:30 p.m. at the Baptist Memorial Hospital.
His actual cause of death is still a bit of a mistery, but it was officially told that he died due to an overdose of prescription drugs that caused him a heart attack.
President Jimmy Carter credited Elvis with having "permanently changed the face of American popular culture".

Thousands of people gathered outside Graceland to view the open casket. One of Elvis' cousins, Billy Mann, accepted $18,000 to secretly photograph the corpse. Alden struck a $105,000 deal with the Enquirer for her story, but settled for less when she broke her exclusivity agreement.
Elvis Presley's funeral was held at Graceland on Thursday, August 18. Outside the gates, a car plowed into a group of  fans, killing two women and critically injuring a third. A funeral procession of 17 white Cadillacs and a hearse carrying the body of of the “King of Rock and Roll” slowly made its way from Graceland to Forrest Hill Cemetery. Under heavy guard, a simple ceremony was conducted. 
About 80,000 people lined the processional route to where Elvis was buried next to his mother. Following an attempt to steal the singer's body in late August, the remains of both Elvis and his mother were reburied in Graceland's Meditation Garden on October 2.
A ground-level gravestone reads "Elvis Aaron Presley", followed by the singer's dates, the names of his parents and daughter, and several paragraphs of smaller text. It is surrounded by flowers, a small American flag. Similar grave markers are visible on either side. In the background is a small round pool, with a low decorative metal fence and several fountains.

Questions
An autopsy, undertaken the same day Elvis died, and was still in progress, when Memphis medical examiner Dr. Jerry Francisco announced that the immediate cause of death was cardiac arrest. 
Cardiac arrhythmia(cardiac arrest), is a condition that can be determined only in someone who is still alive. When Elvis was found, he was lifeless and blue. When asked if drugs were involved, he declared that "drugs played no role in Presley's death". "Drug use was heavily implicated" in Elvis' death, writes Guralnick. 

The pathologists conducting the autopsy thought it possible, that he had suffered "anaphylactic shock brought on by the codeine pills he had gotten from his dentist, to which he was known to have had a mild allergy". 

A pair of lab reports filed two months later strongly suggested that polypharmacy was the primary cause of death.
 One report stated that "fourteen drugs in Elvis' system, ten in significant quantity".

In 1979, forensic pathologist Cyril Wecht conducted a review of the reports. He  concluded that a combination of central nervous system depressants had resulted in Elvis' accidental death. Forensic historian and pathologist Michael Baden said that "Elvis had had an enlarged heart for a long time. That, together with his drug habit, caused his death. But he was difficult to diagnose; it was a judgment call."

A 1981 trial of Elvis' main physician, Dr. George Nichopoulos, exonerated him of criminal liability for the singer's death.
"In the first eight months of 1977 alone, he had (prescribed) more than 10,000 doses of sedatives, amphetamines, and narcotics: all in Elvis's name." 

His license was suspended for three months. It was permanently revoked in the 1990's after the Tennessee Medical Board brought new charges of over-prescription. In 1994, Elvis' autopsy report was reopened. Dr. Joseph Davis declared at its completion, "There is nothing in any of the data that supports a death from drugs. 
In fact, everything points to a sudden, violent heart attack."

In the last years some apparent new evidence came out about his death. More recent research has revealed that it was only Dr. Francisco who told the news people that Elvis apparently died of heart failure. The doctors "could say nothing with confidence until they got the results back from the laboratories, if then. 
That would be a matter of weeks." 

One of the examiners, Dr. E. Eric Muirhead stated that he "could not believe his ears. Francisco had not only presumed to speak for the hospital's team of pathologists, he had announced a conclusion that they had not reached. Early on, a meticulous dissection of the body ... confirmed (that)Elvis was chronically ill with diabetes, glaucoma, and constipation. As they proceeded, the doctors saw evidence that his body had been wracked over a span of years by a large and constant stream of drugs. They had also studied his hospital records, which included two admissions for drug detoxification and methadone treatments."

So, Frank Coffey's opinion that the cause of Elvis' death is "a phenomenon called the Valsalva maneuver"(straining on the toilet leading to heart stoppage)plausible because Elvis suffered constipation, (a common reaction to drug use). In 2013, Dr. Forest Tennant, who had testified as a defense witness in Nichopoulos's trial, described his own analysis of all of Elvis' available medical records. He stated that the "drug abuse had led to falls, head trauma, and overdoses that damaged his brain", and that his death was due in part to a toxic reaction to codeine, exacerbated by an undetected liver enzyme defect, which can cause sudden cardiac arrhythmia. DNA analysis in 2014 of a hair sample reported to be Elvis' found evidence of genetic variants that can lead to glaucoma, migraines, and obesity; which is associated with the heart-muscle disease hypertrophic cardiomyopathy was also identified.

Interesting Facts
Jesse Garon Presley, his identical twin brother, was delivered 35 minutes before him, stillborn.

Elvis loved go-carting, karate, touch football, gospel singing, numerology. Along with that, he also enjoyed board games like Monopoly and Yahtzee.
Elvis had movie idol, Tony Curtis, who had shiny black hair.

Elvis' natural hair color was brown and he used to dye his hair in black. However, he also dyed his eyelashes.

He is the best-selling solo artist in the history of recorded music. 
He won three competitive Grammys.

Elvis recorded 15 songs with the word “blue” in the title.

He received no formal music training and could not read music. He played by ear. 

He was told that he would never make it as a singer.

When Elvis was discharged from the army he was a sergeant.

Elvis endorsed only one product in his entire life i.e. Texas-based Southern Maid Doughnuts.

He received a kidnap-assassination threat. As a safety measure, he performed with a pistol in each of his boots.

There were around 170 impersonators when he died in 1977.  Today, there are around 250,000 impersonators.

Graceland was opened to the public in 1982. It attracts over half a million visitors annually. It is the second most-visited home in the United States, after the White House. It was declared a National Historic Landmark in 2006.

Elvis has been inducted into five music halls of fame: the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (1986), the Country Music Hall of Fame (1998), the Gospel Music Hall of Fame (2001), the Rockabilly Hall of Fame (2007), and the Memphis Music Hall of Fame (2012).
 In 1984, he received the W. C. Handy Award from the Blues Foundation and the Academy of Country Music's  Golden Hat Award. In 1987, he received the American Music Awards' Award of Merit.

Elvis was 6 feet tall and wore a size 11 shoe.

Graceland Mansion was named by its previous owner after his daughter, Grace.

In Las Vegas in 1969, while performing "Are You Lonesome Tonight?", Elvis did one of his frequent lyric changes to amuse himself. Instead of "Do you gaze at your doorstep and picture me there?", he sang "Do you look at your bald head and wish you had hair?"

Elvis' 1960 hit "It's Now or Never" inspired a prisoner who heard it in jail. The prisoner he vowed to pursue a career in music upon his release. The artist, Barry White, was then serving a 4-month sentence for stealing tires.

He was distantly related to former U.S. Presidents Abraham Lincoln and Jimmy Carter.

Elvis recorded more than 600 songs, but did not write any of them.

In 1958, he was trained in martial arts under Jurgen Seydel; during his army duties in Germany, and was awarded the Black Belt before his return to the United States by Hank Slemansky. His karate name was “Tiger.”

Elvis bought Franklin Roosevelt’s presidential yacht and donated it to St. Jude Children's Hospital. In addition to giving away cars, jewelry and cash to friends and strangers, he performed a number of benefit concerts. In 1961, he generated more than $50,000 toward the completion of the USS Arizona Memorial in Hawaii. 
He worked on the project, a tribute to the more than 1,100 men who died aboard the USS Arizona during the 1941 Pearl Harbor attack, had begun years earlier then stalled due to a lack of funds. 
Elvis’ concert, for which tickets ranged from $3 to $100, helped reinvigorate fund-raising efforts for the memorial, and it was dedicated the following year.

Is he still alive?
Since his death, there have been numerous alleged sightings of Elvis Presley. A long-standing conspiracy theory is that he faked his death. There was alleged discrepancies in the death certificate.
Reports of a wax dummy in his original coffin, and accounts of Elvis planning a diversion so he could retire in peace. There were reports at the time that a black helicopter landed at Graceland just before his body was discovered.
In January last year, a new picture taken at Elvis Presley 's former home supposedly offered fans proof he is still alive. Fans are now saying the singer visited his Graceland home on his 82nd birthday last year. Images show a large man with white hair and a white beard standing among the crowd as a cake-cutting ceremony took place last Sunday on the front lawn of the King's house. He was wearing a dark jacket, a black baseball cap as well as sunglasses and watches on as the birthday celebrations take place at the home in Memphis, Tennessee.
Some people claimed he appeared as an extra in the 1990 blockbuster, Home Alone and say he appeared in the background of the scene when Kevin McCallister's mum unsuccessfully attempts to to Chicago.

One of the biggest theories on why Presley may have faked his death is because he had to in order to escape the mob. Gail Brewer-Giorgio, the author of the 1988 bestselling book Is Elvis Alive , said how she pored through thousands of FBI documents to come to the conclusion that Presley was an American hero who had to go into witness protection.
“Do I know if Elvis is alive today? No, I don’t know," she said. "But I know he didn’t die on Aug. 16.”

In a 2005 interview with Oprah, Elvis' wife Priscilla was addressing how Presley spoiled their daughter, Lisa Marie. Priscilla said: “It’s exactly what he said the other day” before correcting herself and saying, “you said,” to Oprah. They also say Lisa Marie evaded Larry King’s question during a 2003 chat when the host asked if she ever feels “communication" with her father.
Do you think Elvis is still alive?

Saturday, July 14, 2018

The Murder of Sandra Bland?

The Murder of Sandra Bland?
Sandra Annette Bland was a 28-year-old African-American woman who was found hanged in a jail cell in Waller County, Texas, on July 13, 2015, three days after a minor traffic violation that escalated.

Her death, was ruled a suicide.

 There were doubts surrounding the cause of death, and alleged racial violence against her.

BEFORE

She was born February 7, 1987 in Naperville, Illinois.
She attended Willowbrook High School in Villa Park, Illinois, then Prairie View A&M University outside Hempstead in Waller County, Texas, where she was a member of the Sigma Gamma Rho sorority. 

She graduated in 2009 with a degree in agriculture.

 At Prairie View, she was recruited as a summer counselor for three years, played in the marching band, and volunteered for a senior citizens advocacy group.

She returned to Illinois in 2009. 

She worked in administration for Cook's, a food-service equipment supplier.

She had been due to start a temporary job on August 3, 2015, with Prairie View as a summer program associate.

In January 2015, she began posting videos  police brutality against blacks.

 In one post she wrote,
"In the news that we've seen as of late, you could stand there, surrender to the cops, and still be killed."

 She was a civil rights activist in Chicago, and a part of the Black Lives Matter movement.

 She had at least ten previous encounters with police in Illinois and Texas.

She owed $7,579 in fines.

THE STOP

Encinia stopped Sandra on the afternoon of July 10, 2015, on University Drive in Prairie View, Texas.

Supposedly she had failed to signal a lane change.

To me, i don't know if the dash cam video really shows that, but i am no expert.

The interaction starts out simple enough.
He pulls her over.

Then he gets out from the vehicle and approaches the passenger side.

He tells her why he pulled her over and asks for her license and registration.

He says he will be back in a few minutes.

Several minutes later the officer comes back to the vehicle, this time on the driver's side.

He asks her what is wrong.

She tells him basically that she is annoyed.

She claims she was just getting out of his way. 

The officer becomes slightly aggitated at her attitude.

He then asks her to put out her cigarette.

She asks him why.

This makes him more upset.

He tells her to get out of the car.

This agitates her.

She refuses. 

He tries repeatedly to pull her out.

He begins yelling at her to get out or he will "light her up."

She says "woah" and gets out of the car.

To me at this point, it is both their faults about this situation getting out of control.

At first i think the officer slightly over reacts.

Then she lets her frustration out verbally.

Then everything goes wrong.

They pretty much go off camera.

What little bit is visible, he keeps making her stand different places and chances his mind what he wants her to do.

Then he gets mad at her for no reason.

Then she starts to freak out.

She cries and screams.

She possibly kicks or hits him at one point "allegedly".

She is then slammed to the ground, face first.

One of the officers is on top of her, her head pressed into the ground.

The officer's knees in her back.

She says she can't hear anything and she is epileptic.
And her arm might be broken.

Officer Encinia yells "Good!"

AND THEN

DPS stated that Sandra was arrested because she kicked Encinia.

 She was charged with assaulting a public servant.

Her bail was set at $5,000.

Sometime she made a call to a friend while she was in jail.

Her friend said she was upbeat despite the arrest: 
"It just makes no sense. 

Sandy was a soldier; she wasn't fazed about it."

THE EVENING OF....

Police stated that at 6:30 a.m. on July 13, Sandra refused breakfast.

A half-hour later told a jailer "I'm fine."

According to Captain Brian Cantrell, about an hour after stating that she was fine, Sandra asked via intercom how to make a phone call.

 Cantrell stated that Sandra was informed she could use the phone in her cell with a PIN.

 He also stated there was no record Sandra made any call.

Police stated that at 9:00 a.m., Sandra was found "in a semi-standing position" hanging in her cell.

NEXT

The next day, after noon, police issued a statement that Sandra had been found dead in her cell, and it appeared that she hung herself.

On July 20, authorities released video from a motion-activated camera in the hallway outside Sandra's cell.

Some of the video was later proven to have been edited.
Also there is a guy being suspicious and trying to hide and throw something away without anyone watching.

 The video shows no movement in and out of the cell from 7:34 to 9:07 a.m..

 She is discovered by a female officer after that time, which led to resuscitation procedures being performed on Sandra's body.

AUTOPSY AND SUCH
Cause of death was asphyxiation, and classified as a suicide.

Police stated that Sandra had used a plastic garbage bag to hang herself.

In pictures of the crime scene, there is still a garabage bag in her garbage, so where did the bag that she supposedly hung herself with come from?

 The autopsy report showed she had multiple abrasions on the right side of her back, slight abrasions on her wrists, and 25 to 30 healing, parallel cuts on her left forearm that predated her arrest.

So that probably happened with her scuffle durring the traffic stop.

An initial toxicology report found "a remarkably high concentration" of THC for someone who had been in jail for three days.

This lead to speculation that Sandra may have had access to marijuana while in jail. 

Waller County assistant district attorney, Warren Diepraam said that it was more likely that Sandra had ingested a very large amount of marijuana prior to her arrest. 

A toxicologist for the Tarrant County medical examiner's office agreed, suggesting she "either had access to the drug in jail or she was a consistent user of the drug and her body had accumulated THC to the point that it was slowly releasing it over time." 

However he added: "I have never seen a report in the literature or from any other source of residual THC that high three days after someone stops using the drug."

FUNERAL AND AFTER

Sandra Bland's funeral was held on July 22 at DuPage African Methodist Episcopal Church in Lisle, Illinois.

Family and friends called for an independent autopsy.
 They didn't think she would kill herself.

Her family said that she was upbeat about the job she was about to begin for Prairie View A&M.

WAS THE POLICE AT FAULT?

The FBI and DPS announced on July 16 that they had launched an investigation into Sandra's death. 

After authorities reviewed the dash cam footage, Encinia was placed on administrative leave for failing to follow proper traffic stop procedures.

 Waller County Sheriff R. Glenn Smith, who runs the jail in which Bland died, has been placed in charge of Waller County's investigation into her death.

 Smith was suspended and fired from his previous post as chief of police of Hempstead after alleged incidents of racism and brutality.

Hmmm.....

A report from the Texas Commission on Jail Standards, published on July 16, found that Waller County jail "guards violated policies by failing to do timely checks on inmates," which should be hourly.
Sandra wasn't checked on for almost 2 hours.

 The report also stated that jail employees had not been adequately trained to deal with mental health problems.

The staff had not all undergone the minimum of two hours of mental health training required by the state.

On July 22, county officials produced intake forms that they say indicate Sandra had attempted suicide in her past.

Yet, they didn't check her like they were supposed to and they didn't remove everything from her cell she could harm herself with.
 One questionnaire states Sandra took pills in 2015 after having a miscarriage.

Another form filed by a different jail employee says Bland attempted suicide earlier, in 2014. 

One form indicates Bland had contemplated suicide within the past year, while another says she did not.

Very confusing...

And there is Sandra's signatures, that don't match on all the forms.
A white male prisoner hanged himself with a bedsheet in 2012 in the same jail.

CURIOUS

In March 2016, documents obtained from the forensic lab that performed Sandra's autopsy suggested that the time of death was not the same as was originally reported by official investigations.

This could raise questions about the validity of the original investigation.

A report by the Harris County forensic investigator contradicted the official report of the Waller County Sheriff's Department.

 The details of the condition of the body differed.

 In addition, the documents stating the time guards last observed Sandra alive in her cell did not agree with the security video footage from the jail where she was detained.

There was a discrepancy of an hour. 

Brandon Wood, director of the Texas Commissioner on Jail Standards said that the failure to observe inmates hourly as required by standards "could be criminal in nature." 

An attorney for the Sandra family said that it might be just a clerical error, or might be something "more nefarious."

AND THEN THIS HAPPENED

In December 2015, a county grand jury declined to issue an indictment in connection to Sandra's death.

 It was stated that "the case is still open", and that the grand jury would meet again in January 2016 to discuss other aspects.

Reconvening the following month, the grand jury indicted Encinia for perjury, a Class A misdemeanor with a possible penalty of one year in jail and a $4,000 fine. 

The charge was because of his statement in an affidavit that his reason for removing Bland from her car was "to further conduct a safe traffic investigation". 

The grand jury found that statement to be false.

Hours after the indictment was announced, DPS said they had begun the process to terminate Encinia's employment as a state trooper.

 After an arrest warrant was issued, he surrendered at the Waller County Jail and was released after posting a $2,500 bond. 

His attorney said that he would appeal his termination.

 Sandra's family called for more serious criminal charges including battery and false arrest.

 On June 28, 2017, a judge granted a motion by prosecutors to dismiss the perjury charge against Encinia.

 In return, Encinia agreed that he would "never seek, accept or engage in employment in any capacity with law enforcement". 

He also agreed not to seek expungement of the perjury charge.

WRONGFUL DEATH

Sandra's family filed a federal wrongful death lawsuit.

 A jury trial in that case was scheduled for January 2017. 

The family sought unspecified damages from DPS, Encinia, Waller County, and two jailers.

 In September 2016, Sandra's family settled the lawsuit for $1.9 million, according to her mother. 

QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

The arresting officer tells Sandra Bland to get out of her car after she declines to put out her cigarette. 
Is that legal?

Yep.

The officer can tell the driver to get out of the car. 

Whether the officer had a legitimate concern for his safety in that moment based on the fact that Sandra was smoking a cigarette while answering his questions is another story.

It just seemed he wanted to punish her for her being perturbed and not wanting to put out her cigarette.

If an officer looks into a car and sees the driver reaching for something or sees maybe a gun or something that could be used as a weapon sticking out of somewhere that would be why an officer has justification to ask a driver to step out of a car. 

Or maybe if they feel like the person is about to drive away, or trying to escape. 

In the video there is no mention that Sandra is suspected of having any kind of weapon or reaching for anything.

Plus, the car isn't even running.

She was calm, she was in her car. She was definitely irritated. 

He asked her why she was irritated. 

She gave him an honest answer. 

He should've gave her a ticket and walked away.

Can Sandra legally refuse to get out of the car?

No.

If you are told to get out of the car, you have to get out.

She said, “Why do I have to get out of my car?” 

She was entitled to ask a question. 

It was his right to answer or not.

He could have simply told her that he was afraid that she might have a weapon or something.

Instead, he decided to scream at her and escalate the situation.

Was the officer allowed to pull his taser on her and threaten her with the words “I’m going to light you up?”

Depends on the department's policy.

Not all are created equal.

The best practices of law enforcement is to use the least amount of force necessary in a situation. 

At the time he could see all of her body; no part of her was making any contact with any part of his body.

 She was verbally questioning his behavior, but she wasn’t threatening him verbally or physically in any way. 

The car wasn’t preparing to leave, there was no indication the car was moving. 

It seems he was just being punitive.

The first thing and officer  should do is try verbal communication. 

The next step is to try something involving using the officer's hands.

 Tasers are supposed to be a last resort, and only a substitute for lethal force. 

Clearly in that situation he was threatening to use it to punish her.

There appears there was absolutely no justification for him to threaten to “light her up” to get her to comply with an order. 

She voluntarily got out of the car.

When Sandra asks him 14 times what she’s being arrested for, is he supposed to tell her?

Nope.

He’s not required by law to answer.

It's generally understood best practice of law enforcement, especially when there’s no dangerous circumstances. 

Obviously, the best practice is to give the person information.

I don’t understand how the arresting officer can tell Sandra she is going to jail for resisting arrest. 

How can you be arrested for resisting arrest?

There has to be a lawful arrest in order to be resisting it. 

The Supreme Court has decided that you can be arrested for a traffic violation, and that it’s entirely up to the officer’s discretion whether they’re going to give you a ticket or arrest you. 

The moment she failed to use her turn signal, he had probable cause to arrest her. 

Are the police allowed to search her car?

Yup.

When she’s under arrest they can search the immediate area around her. 

And in this case they were impounding the car because she isn’t going to drive anywhere, so they’re allowed to search it before impounding it.

Is Sandra, as far as you can tell, being arrested or being detained? 

What are the differences between the two?

There is a point when he is telling her to get out of the car.

She asks why she is being told to get out of the car if she is not under arrest.

He tells her she is under arrest.

 She then asks, "For what? For failure to use a turn signal?"

She was justifiably frustrated.

He was clearly exercising his discretion in a discriminatory manner.

Being detained is being detained for investigation for a crime, and being arrested is being taken into custody. 

In a traffic stop there is a gray moment where the officer has probable cause to arrest you for a traffic violation.

You're being detained for further investigation for whether you have warrants, whether your license is valid, whether you are driving with insurance and if the investigation for those things turns up clean then usually officers exercise their discretion to issue you a ticket.

The arresting officer is heard speaking off-camera to someone. 

He is trying to figure out what to charge her with. 

Is this typical? 

To try and figure out what to charge a suspect with?

Yes... ish.

You have to have reasonable suspicion and probable cause.

Afterwards yes, people do sit around and figure out what official charges to bring.

At the very end of the video the arresting officer tells Sanda she is under arrest. 

Was she not under arrest before when he told her she was going to jail?

As soon as she told her she was going to jail and had cuffs on her, she was under arrest. 

Miranda rights: I didn’t hear the officer read them to her. 
Is he required to?

Nope.

He is only required to read them to her after she is under arrest and if he is interrogating her.

Off-camera, Sandra is heard saying her head was slammed against the pavement, but we can’t see it.

 What do you make of that?

She said she can’t hear, she can’t feel her arm, he slammed her head on the pavement and she has epilepsy.

They should have called medical attention for her.

Could this have all been avoided?

How?

Yup.

Especially since the incident escalated after he ran her license and registration. 

The incident should have ended in a warning or citation. 

He asked her why she was irritated and she told him. 

He shouldn’t have asked that question if he didn’t want an honest answer. And once he got the honest answer he should have let it go. 

He escalated by asking her to put out her cigarette. 

It’s not illegal to smoke in your own car. 

And it’s not illegal to smoke during a police encounter.

THE ARRESTING OFFICER
Brian Encinia was 30 years old at the time of the incident.

 He was listed in Texas voter records as Hispanic.

 He graduated from Texas A&M University in 2008 with a degree in agricultural leadership and development. 

From 2008 to 2014, he held a position with Blue Bell Creameries as an ingredient-processing supervisor. 

Prior to his employment as a state trooper in 2014, he served as a volunteer firefighter with the Brenham fire department for four years.

What do you think happened?

Was it murder?

I think that at the very least the arresting officer didn't handle the traffic stop well at all.

He escalated things.

When Sandra became frustrated, he became very angry and empowered.

He had plenty of opportunities to defuse the situation before it got physical.

He was suppose to be professional.

As to what happened after she was arrested? 

I believe we are not getting the whole story.

There was some shady things going on.

They were at least careless regarding Sandra's safety.

This is the Dash Cam Video.

This video raises some interesting questions about after her death.
Fishy things seem to be going on.

This video takes a more neutral view.
It proves some interesting points.

This is what Anonymous thinks.