Sarah May Kilgore was born on January 25th, 1980, to Eugenia Perry. Sarah had a big heart, and she would help anyone. Sadly, she lost her two brothers, one in 1990 and the other one in 1999.
Sarah and her mother were very close, they'd talk several times a day. She had five boys.
Sarah was last seen walking in her Indianapolis, Indiana neighborhood on October 9, 2011. She has never been heard from again.
A few weeks before Sarah went missing, she had called her mother and told her that she feared for her life. Her mother called 911 and asked for a welfare check. A policemen called her back after the welfare check and warned her not to do it again or he would have her arrested. A few days after that, Sarah went and visited her mom for a few days with a friend named Nikki Knapp. During that visit Sarah had told one of her brother's that she was fearful of a man named Rondell Castine. Sarah's mother begged her to stay but she wouldn't listen and headed back home.
Eugenia talked to her daughter several times a day for about five days. Eugenia said that her daughter seemed ok, but then after the five days she was unable to get a hold of her, so Sarah's dad went over to her house to check on her. Her dad was surprised to find where Sarah was living to be completely empty as though there was no one living there.
The police refused to let Kilgore's family file a missing person report until 30 days had passed. She is originally from southern Indiana.
It should be noted that Sarah had a boyfriend named Daniel who was a married man.
At the time of her disappearance, she was 31 years old, 5'7, 120 - 130 pounds with Auburn/brown hair, blue eyes. She has a tattoo of the name "Patrick" on her lower back and a tattoo of the cartoon character Tweety Bird on her right leg. She has dimples when she smiles.
If you have any information on Sarah's whereabouts, please contact Indianapolis Police Department 317-327-6915.
Sarah had a grandson born this year that her family would love her to meet. They all miss her dearly.
"I miss how she would help me she would come over and do anything I needed done. I miss her smile she had dimples. I just miss everything about her." ~Eugenia Perry
Back in 2019 there was a possible sighting of Sarah at a casino in Ohio as well as at a dollar store in Indiana in 2021.
