Mysteries That Were Solved By Psychics: Case #2 Susan Jacobson

Susan Jacobson

On May 15, 1976, she left her Staten Island home to go to a job interview at an ice cream parlor. 

When she didn't return for dinner, her parents contacted police. 

The police said that she had probably run away with her boyfriend.

Devastated by the lack of police support, two weeks later, the Jacobsons asked psychic Dorothy Allison to help with the case.

Dorothy Allison asked the missing girl's parents what the numbers "2, 5, 6, 2" meant.
Susan's parents said that that was Susan's birthday, February 5th, 1962.
Dorothy then asked about the numbers "408 or 405".

It turns out that that is the time when Susan was born.
She asked what "Mar" meant and stated that she wanted to see Mar.

Dorothy then stated that Susan had been strangled by her boyfriend. The authorities refused to work with a psychic,

So Susan's father, Bill,  worked with the clues involving an abandoned car, letters "MAR" in red spray paint, the smell of oil, two sets of dual church steeples, two smoke stacks, swamps and marshes.

Dorothy said that she suspect it was Susan's boyfriend, Dempsey Hawkins.

Susan's parents continued searching until they found a place called "Downback".

It had an abandoned World War I ship yard, and they found a rock that had the letters "MAR" in red spray paint.

Susan's body was found two years later in two oil drums, from where a person could see two church steeples, two smoke stacks and an abandoned car. 

Susan had been strangled to death and placed in the oil drum, hence the smell of oil, and then thrown into a hole with a water-filled swamp below.
Dempsey Hawkins, Susan's boyfriend, was arrested, tried, and convicted of her murder, just as Dorothy predicted. 

In 2017, Dempsey Hawkins was paroled and deported from the United States.